September 2006 Book Reviews

September was a truly exhausting month. It involved a cross-country trip (or at least mid-country), a birthday weekend getaway, 10+ hours of freelance work, and one complete house move, which was just completed last night. So very little reading. Here's what I managed to read on the commuter train:

1. Gramercy Park, Carole Klein, Rating: 3.9
I remember exactly when I got this book - while in summer school at NYU in 1999. It's been on my shelf ever since, waiting to be read. I had a vague idea that it was some sort of late nineteenth century work of american lit. That was completely wrong - it's actually a non-fiction history of the neighborhood in New York City. It's surprisingly compelling. The author essentially strings together a series of mini-biographies of famous New Yorkers who were in some way affiliated with the neighborhood. Definitely not for everyone, but I really enjoyed it.
2. Veronica, Mary Gaitskill, Rating: 3.4
I seem to see this book everywhere these days. It follows one woman along a trail of bad decisions through the '80s and '90s. AIDS and other related diseases feature prominently. The story is unique and thought-provoking. I'm not recommending it strongly, but it's definitely better than most contemporary fiction.
3. Cellophane, Maria Arana, Rating: 4.3
I am strongly recommending this one -- if you're a fan of magical realism. The story is completely fantastic, whimsical and sexy, at times hilarious. It's escapism at its best. I would strongly recommend this as a vacation read.
4. Cry, The Beloved Country, Alan Paton, Rating: 3.5
What a downer this book is. Purposefully so, clearly, and there's no denying it's extremely effective, but it's really sad.
As a side note, the intro is really interesting - Paton finished his manuscript in San Francisco and loaned it to a couple he had met on the train. They went to extraordinary lengths to get the book published - had found the publisher, had the manuscript typed (the whole thing in a matter of days - they worked around the clock), arranged all of Paton's meetings. All for a virtual stranger.
5. Mother Tongue, Bill Bryson, Rating: 4.1
This book has been on my list forever. My aunt has a copy on her shelf and I read a chapter or so whenever I'm over at her house. She recently took a nice long trip to Italy, which gave me enough time to finish it. While wikipedia takes issue with its level of accuracy, it's thought-provoking, raises innumerable interesting points, is full of conversation-starters, and it's often hilarious. Can we ask for much more from a book? The subject: the English language.
6. Pledged, Alexandra Robbins, Rating: 2.8
This book saved me on the never-ending flights to and from Chicago. The secret life of sororities - doesn't that say it all? Actually, it didn't really. While the book is definitely interesting, there are no secrets. No real opinions. No real facts, when you get right down to it. Just one writer with a good idea, and sloppy research techniques. There's definitely room for a more definitive book on the subject. This isn't to say that it's not entertaining - it is - but it leaves you wanting a lot more.